Wind farm cause for concern

Montgomery County landowners have begun breaking ground for the 100 turbine wind farm in Sugar Creek and Madison townships. Plans began in 2008, and were finalized in 2013. I encourage anyone living in rural Montgomery County to view the document online at the county recorder’s website. The economic development agreement between Sugar Creek Wind LLC and Montgomery County, Indiana, features a road use plan showing tower locations. Residents need to know where these towers will be placed.

Some experts state the safe distance for living beside a wind tower is 2-3 miles. In 2009, commissioners decided the towers can be placed just 1,300 feet from your property line. Research has been done worldwide that has proven potential health effects from living too close to wind towers include sleep disturbances, headaches, anxiety, memory dysfunction, dizziness and high blood pressure, to name just a few. In Brown County, Wisconsin, the health department there declared their local wind project a “human health hazard.” In Oklahoma, it was ruled that turbines cannot be placed more than 1.5 miles from schools. Indiana is lagging in its wind power regulation. Next door in District 54 Indiana State Rep. Tom Saunders wants a temporary suspension of wind development in Indiana due in part to the health issues they can cause.

I attended an economic development plan public workshop April 12. Participants were asked to place dots on places in the county where they felt industry should be. I heard some people comment that it was not a good practice to tell others what they should have in their backyard. The 2013 agreement exhibit B description of the development area states Madison and Sugar Creek townships as “undesirable for ... normal development and occupancy because of a lack of development, cessation of growth, deterioration of improvements or character of occupancy, ages, obsolescence, substandard buildings.” I am amazed at the county’s description of the rural community which I treasure, and I fear the power of the almighty dollar is what’s driving this skewed view. If our townships are in fact so run down, it does not make sense to reduce property values by adding a highly-contested factor like a wind farm.

The wind industry is actively recruiting landowners in Coal Creek township. It may be too late for us in the eastern part of the county. I just remind those in the west to be informed as early as possible. The wind farm companies Apex and Akua are powerful corporations which have proven to not pay much mind to the rights and safety of the little guy. Not many of us were paying attention in 2008. The whole county needs to pay attention now. Don’t let the dot get put on you. Join us now on Facebook at No Wind Farm Montgomery County IN.

Tisha Southwood


More from this section

A wave of protests is roiling Moscow. Millions of people, young and old, have been crowding the streets in Hong Kong. In Britain, members of the Conservative Party took to open revolt over Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s move to sideline Parliament on Brexit. If democracy is dysfunctional and… Read more

(3) comments


Mr. Alvarez claims there have been 20 studies showing that wind farms are not hazardous. Unfortunately, there have been hundreds of other studies which show evidence to the contrary. provides ready access to 422 such research studies. I also refer readers to this same website to see testimonials of people across the country who have fallen ill due to wind farms. Their stories of having to abandon their homes are heartbreaking. But what is really at stake here is the health and development of our children. Is it ethical to take this kind of risk with their lives? Tennessee just voted last week to freeze all of their wind farm development for at least one year. Knowing what we do about wind farms, Indiana should be taking such cautious measures as well.


I imagine most of our residents/voters would prefer a coal mine or another coal burning power plant - to a wind farm.


Indiana has a valuable natural resource that’s ready for harvest. Wind energy can deliver a big economic boost to communities – creating jobs, paying millions in property taxes and leases to landowners, and generating clean, homegrown electricity from a source that will never run out.

While there are plenty of Hoosiers who see the benefits of wind, some have questioned whether it’s right for them. When changes to our communities are proposed, we want to be sure they’re in harmony with a safe place to live.

Let me set the record straight.

Hundreds of thousands of people live near wind farms around the world without experiencing health issues. Over 20 peer-reviewed studies have found no evidence of harm from proximity to wind turbines. Credible research from MIT, the Massachusetts Department of Public Health, the Wisconsin Department of Public Health, and Canada’s equivalent of the Department of Health and Human Services bears this out.

Besides being safe, wind energy also helps us preserve our clean air. A Harvard study found $7.4 billion in public health benefits from wind in 2016 alone, because of how much pollution it avoids that would otherwise cause unhealthy smog and trigger asthma attacks.

We all plug things in. More wind power gets that energy as cleanly and cheaply as possible. It’s an economic powerhouse for the communities that host it. And we can breathe easier knowing our communities will stay healthy and safe.

-Greg Alvarez, American Wind Energy Association

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.