Imagine a virus as a fire, moving wherever it finds someone susceptible. Each immune person creates a barrier, giving the flames fewer places to go. The College of Physicians of Philadelphia’s History of Vaccines website uses this metaphor to explain herd immunity: protecting ourselves can also help protect our neighbors.
Although ideas of inoculation go back centuries and the first vaccinations began in the 1800s, the idea of herd immunity only emerged in the early 1900s out of livestock farming. At the time, scientists studying herds noticed that when most animals survived a disease and became immune, the whole group became safer. Disease had fewer susceptible hosts through which to travel. Vaccination offers a way to build that protection without first enduring the illness and its risks.
Individual decisions and community health are connected. In a recent Lunch with the League, Montgomery County Health Department physician Scott Douglas reviewed why vaccines are recommended. He explained why preventing serious disease remains important even when a shot cannot prevent every infection.
Vaccines protect people throughout life, particularly as age or conditions like cancer, diabetes, and others that compromise immunity increase the likelihood that an infection will lead to hospitalization.
Douglas focused on influenza, COVID-19 and respiratory syncytial virus, or RSV. Using hospitalization graphs, he illustrated how seasonal infections translate into hospital admissions. Behind those curves are people whose breathing, strength and ability to manage other medical conditions can deteriorate when a respiratory virus strikes.
For COVID-19, Douglas emphasized the distinction between preventing infection and preventing its worst consequences. He described vaccination as providing additional protection even among people whose immune systems have encountered the virus before. A breakthrough infection does not, by itself, mean vaccination accomplished nothing.
He also addressed a familiar objection to influenza vaccination: “The last time I got the vaccine, I got the flu.” The injected flu vaccines he discussed contain no virus capable of causing influenza. Getting sick after a vaccination does not mean the shot caused the illness.
RSV presents a challenge, specifically for babies and toddlers. Douglas described the anxiety it can cause parents and physicians caring for struggling infants. Protection can begin during pregnancy, when vaccination allows maternal antibodies to reach the baby. Infants may alternatively receive protective monoclonal antibodies; those are ready-made defenses, not vaccines. Older adults and people with certain underlying conditions also warrant attention to RSV prevention.
Measles demonstrates why community protection matters so much. On Nov. 4, IU Health reported that Indiana had gone from eight cases on Sept. 2 to over 100. As of the day this piece was written, Nov. 13, cases increased to 171, according to the Indiana Department of Health.
“Measles is very contagious, and the virus can remain in the air for up to two hours. People with measles can spread the disease approximately four days before they even get a rash, and up to four days after the rash starts,” says the IDOH measles webpage, which is also reporting which counties have how many cases. Two doses of the MMR vaccine, often given in childhood, provide lifelong immunity and prevent community transmission, protecting infants too young for the vaccine.
Not every vaccine, however, works chiefly by interrupting community transmission. Shingles vaccination protects against an individual’s painful illness and its potentially lasting aftermath. The CDC recommends two doses of Shingrix for adults 50 and older, and for certain younger adults with weakened immune systems. The vaccine also helps prevent postherpetic neuralgia, nerve pain that can persist for months or years.
Vaccination can even prevent some cancers. Hepatitis B can become a chronic infection that damages the liver and leads to liver cancer. Preventing that infection through vaccination can interrupt a process whose consequences might otherwise emerge years later.
The human papillomavirus vaccine offers another cancer-prevention opportunity. HPV causes several cancers, including cervical cancer. Vaccination prevents new infections rather than treating existing ones, which is why protection works best before exposure. These are vaccines against infections with consequences extending far beyond an initial illness. Notably, new vaccines that could prevent the deadly pancreatic cancer are in development.
Adults should review their vaccination history and discuss age, health conditions and eligibility with a qualified clinician. The Montgomery County health department provides both free vaccines to eligible individuals and recommendations on age and need. For more information, see https://www.in.gov/localhealth/montgomerycounty/nursing-and-immunizations/.
Vaccination is one way individual preparation becomes shared protection — especially for people too young to be vaccinated or whose immune systems cannot build adequate defenses.
The League of Women Voters, a non-partisan, multi-issue organization encourages informed and active participation in government, works to increase public understanding of major policy issues and influences public policy through education and advocacy. All men and women are invited to join the LWV where hands-on work to safeguard democracy leads to civic improvement. For information, visit the website www.lwvmontcoin.org or the League of Women Voters of Montgomery County, IN Facebook page.