INDIANAPOLIS — U.S. Sen. Jim Banks projects himself as a kingmaker, like President Donald J. Trump. But instead of boosting the Indiana Republican Party’s prospects, he became a wrecking ball after the May primary and November midterm elections.
Banks fostered a costly, fratricidal demolition derby for Hoosier Republicans. I count 10 seats where he directly contributed to GOP losses. It would have been worse by another five congressional seats if the redistricting maps that Trump and Vice President JD Vance schemed and Team Banks fulsomely supported had become reality.
“In the Senate, you had 21 Republican state senators join the Democrats to literally thumb their nose at President Trump and, really, the Republicans all over the country who are begging Republicans to fight back,” Banks told the “Clay & Buck Show” in April.
“For some reason, we still have this bastion of anti-Trump Republicanism in the state of Indiana, and I’m trying to lead the way to fix that. In fact, we’re spending millions of dollars to oust some of these anti-Trump Republican state senators.”
Banks ardently embraced Trump’s mid-decade redistricting scheme. It was Banks who, on Jan. 18, 2026, posted on X, “We need new leadership in the Indiana Senate.” It was Banks who helped organize and fund a $15 million dark money campaign against Republican state senators who voted against that scheme in December 2025. It was Banks who endorsed embattled Secretary of State Diego Morales and then pulled that support after the May primary as the corruption narrative took hold.
As a kingmaker, he selected an obscure staffer, Max Engling, to take on Morales at the Republican convention.
As all this internecine warfare unfolded, I called it the “Indiana Republican civil war.” How did this all turn out after the Nov. 3 election? It was pure Trump-style American carnage, a demolition derby that has transformed the Indiana GOP moving forward.
And the fruits of Banks’ kingmaking labor?
1. If the proposed new maps that the Indiana House approved and the Indiana Senate rejected last December had been in place for the Nov. 3 election, Democrats would have won eight out of nine congressional seats. Only U.S. Rep. Erin Houchin would have survived, and by less than 1%. In reality, only U.S. Rep. Victoria Spartz lost, leaving Hoosier Republicans with a 5-3 delegation advantage.
2. Trump’s retribution campaign against the seven senators who voted no ended up costing five renominations. Sens. Dan Dernulc, Linda Rogers, Travis Holdman, Jim Buck and Greg Walker all lost their primary races. Another adjacent senator to Dernulc’s Lake County District, Rick Niemeyer, was also defeated. Targeted Sens. Greg Goode and Spencer Deery won their primaries, but at tremendous cost. Deery spent $1.056 million defending his seat; Goode spent $841,714.
3. Of the six Senate seats where Republican incumbents lost in primaries, two of the nominees — Trevor De Vries and Brian Schmutzler — lost on Nov. 3, kicking those seats to Democrats. This carnage has spread to the General Assembly leadership, with House Speaker Todd Huston’s upset and Banks’ alternative to Senate President Pro Tem Rodric Bray being Sen. Chris Garten, R-Charlestown, whose own reelection bid has yet to be certified.
4. Banks issued vociferous criticism of another Republican senator — Liz Brown of Fort Wayne. He backed Darren Vogt, who Brown defeated in the primary by 14 votes and then was upset Democrat Julie McGill, 52%-48%, on Nov. 3. That makes three Indiana Senate seat losses directly attributed to Banks’ maneuvering.
4. The $15 million of Republican dark money spent in the primary branded reliably conservative Republican senators like Brown Buck, Holdman and Walker as “liberals.”
5. Banks’ choice for secretary of state, Engling, lost to Democrat Beau Bayh by 9%. The collateral damage also included Republican Comptroller Elise Nieshalla, who was upset by Democrat Jessica Bailey. These were the first Republican statewide candidates to lose since 2012.
If you’re keeping score, that’s six incumbent GOP senators defeated in the primary as direct or indirect retribution campaign casualties; three more in the general election; Engling and Nieshalla on the statewide races; and potentially six incumbent members of Congress who had the redistricting scheme passed. That comes to 10 actual seats lost and six potential defeats under the new maps. If you add Huston’s upset defeat after he embraced the redistricting scheme as collateral damage to this Republican circular firing squad, that makes it 17.
This GOP civil war brought with it an ugly, violent component, as a number of these challenged senators and Braun were targeted with swatting attempts. An Indiana State Police and FBI investigation has resulted in no criminal charges.
Banks was obviously following the lead on not only the post-redistricting scheme but also Trump’s kingmaking antics.
“There’s no way to spin it. It was a bad night for Republicans,” Banks said on WIBC-FM’s “The Hammer and Nigel Show” on Nov. 4. “I’m surprised by how bad it was all over the country and not just in Indiana.”
Asked if Trump’s war of choice that he launched against Iran on Feb. 28 had an impact on voters, Banks responded by citing recent comments from the vice president.
“JD Vance is right, you can’t untangle high gas prices from the War in Iran,” Banks told WIBC-FM. On July 6, he told Fox News, “Well, I give President Trump so much credit because he doesn’t look at this as an election issue. Some things are more important than elections.”
As for Trump’s tariffs and immigration crackdown, which have hammered Hoosier farmers, American automakers, home builders and buyers, and top Indiana trading partners Canada and Mexico, Banks is still on board.
“With the tariff situation, I support President Trump’s trade agenda,” Banks said on WIBC.
Banks has repeatedly praised Trump, calling him the “greatest president of my lifetime” and the “strongest president.”
Brian A. Howey is an opinion columnist for State Affairs Indiana and the founder of Howey Politics Indiana. His writing offers analysis and opinion shaped by decades of experience covering Indiana politics. Email him at howey@stateaffairs.com.